Why they are so widespread
Tools like Zabbix and Nagios have been in the field for years and cover a very wide range of checks. No licence cost, everything configurable, and a large community are why many teams start here.
In a small or mid-sized environment, building solid monitoring with these tools is entirely possible. It is more realistic to start the evaluation with 'what can this team sustain' than with 'which one is better'.
Where teams struggle in practice
The difficulty usually shows up in the second year, not at installation. Checks multiply, thresholds get tuned to one person's judgement, that person moves on, and the reasons behind the configuration are never written down.
- Alert noise: dozens of separate notifications when one switch goes down
- Maintenance load: version upgrades, plugin compatibility, template upkeep
- Knowledge held by one person: only one colleague understands the setup
- The incident story is lost: when it started, what was tried, what worked
Questions worth asking
What makes tool selection easier is not a feature list but a few clear questions about your own environment.
- Who maintains this tool, and what happens while they are on leave?
- During an outage, how many notifications does the team get, and how many lead to action?
- Do last month's incidents still exist as records, including what was done?
- How will devices on a private network be reached?
- Are certificate and domain expiry dates being tracked?
Where Sentry sits
Sentry focuses less on the breadth of checks and more on understanding the incident: it reads live reachability checks together with syslog records and produces an incident summary, probable causes, and steps that can be reviewed. Steps are never applied automatically; for anything that risks an outage, the decision belongs to the operator.
This is not a claim of superiority, just a different centre of gravity. If your current Zabbix setup serves you well, there is no urgent reason to replace it; if your pain is alert volume and incident review, it is worth comparing.